China must be held liable for letting the Covid pandemic spread to the world

What Others Are Saying

Rabbi Menahem ben Solomon Meiri, (1249-1315), the famous Catalan rabbi, Talmudist and Maimonidean, who lived in Perpignan, Catalonia, Provence, wrote: “Just as the government is obligated to protest injustices amongst the people, so are people obligated to protest injustices in the government.”


“Many advocates of the rule of law say Beijing should be held liable for the worldwide consequences of its misfeasance,” writes David Kilgour.

    by David Kilgour

Even before the Covid-19 pandemic, nine in ten Canadians held a negative impression of the government of China, according to a 2019 Nanos national opinion survey.

Many people in countries with independent media probably know that during about 40 days in late 2019 and early 2020 Beijing concealed and falsified information about the spread of Covid-19 within the country.

German intelligence and others report that China’s Xi Jinping pressured the World Health Organisation (WHO) to delay issuing a global warning about the virus. Beijing suppressed the information to give it time to buy up personal protective equipment and other medical supplies globally,  according to a Department of Homeland Security report quoted by the Associated Press.

When Covid emerged in Wuhan, Taiwan President Tsai Ing-wen moved quickly to screen flights from there on December 31, 2019; ban Wuhan residents on January 23; institute intensive testing and contact tracing; and bar all visitors from China on February 6. If the WHO and its 194 member-nations had adapted Taiwan’s practices, many of the infections and deaths worldwide could have been avoided.

President Tsai Ing-wen, ROC

The biggest influx of Covid carriers into Europe was about 260,000 Chinese citizens, with two-thirds flying back to their jobs in Italy. By January 11, 2021, there were 2.2 million confirmed cases in Italy and 79,203 deaths.

European Union governments, Australia, and the US have demanded an independent investigation into how Covid-19 spread to humans. Xi offered $2 billion to the WHO, but until mid-January 2021 blocked WHO and investigators from various countries from entering Wuhan. Some class actions for damages against the government of China appear already to be underway in the United States.

Many advocates of the rule of law say Beijing should be held liable for the worldwide consequences of its misfeasance, which now include more than 101 million infections worldwide, over two million deaths and about 400 million jobs lost. The global economic loss to date is estimated at about US$16 trillion.

The pandemic also underlined the fact that Canada and many democracies are overly dependent on China for medicines, PPE and manufactured goods. Canada alone has lost about 600,000 manufacturing jobs since 2000. Another major consideration for Canadians is Xi’s “hostage diplomacy” and his regime’s arrest of Michael Kovrig and Michael Spavor, who have spent more than two years in harsh prison conditions. 

           Michael Kovrig and Michael Spavor

A Canadian Security Intelligence Service academic outreach concluded: “Under (Xi’s) leadership, the Party-state is staging a vehement attack on Western democracy and values.” One egregious example is the state of democratic governance and the rule of law today in Hong Kong.

Beijing has, for decades, been accused of conducted organ-harvesting from thousands of prisoners of conscience – Falun Gong, Uyghur Muslims, Tibetans, Christians and others. The despicable commerce is documented in Bloody Harvest (2009) by David Matas and the writer, The Slaughter (2014) by Ethan Gutmann, and a 201 Update.

                    Irwin Cotler

Canada’s Irwin Cotler and Matas recently proposed a number of remedies for the Covid damages caused by the government of China, including:

  • The International Court of Justice (ICJ) – Any UN member state can ask the UN General Assembly to make a request to the ICJ for an advisory opinion on a legal question. China would not be able to use its veto.
  • The WHO’s behaviour in the current pandemic is disappointing. Instead of China reforming its policies/practices, it was the WHO that altered its approach to accommodate Beijing. If interventions in China had begun three weeks earlier, transmission of Covid-19 could have been reduced by 95 per cent, according to a study by the U.K’s University of Southampton.
  • The Magnitsky laws, named for murdered Russian whistle-blower Sergei Magnitsky, allow for the public listing of human rights violators and subjects them to visa bans/asset seizures. The six countries with such legislation should pursue accountability for those in China who allowed Covid-19 to become a global pandemic.

Francis Fukuyama, formerly of America’s National Endowment for Democracy, observes correctly: “We aren’t dealing with the China of the 1990s or… 2000s, but a completely different animal that represents a clear challenge to our democratic values.” It must be held at bay until it returns to being a more normal authoritarian country, he concludes.

        Marc Garneau

The responsible international community must act to safeguard global public health; indulging gross negligence or worse in Xi’s China carries a long-term cost. Preventing another pandemic requires pursuing accountability against Beijing now. We must all speak up for the dignity of those who perished. The first step is holding those responsible for spreading Covid-19 to pay damages.

Canada’s new Foreign Minister, Marc Garneau, is capable of working effectively with the new Biden administration on more coordinated multilateral engagements with Beijing.

David Kilgour, in Canada’s Liberal government, served as the Deputy Speaker (1993–1997) and Chairman of Committees of the Whole of the House of Commons, Secretary of State (Latin America and Africa) (1997–2002), and Secretary of State (Asia-Pacific) (2002–2003). In the Conservative governments of Joe Clark and Brian Mulroney, he served as Parliamentary Secretary to the President of the Privy Council, the Minister for CIDA, the Minister of Indian and Northern Affairs, and the Minister of Transport.

Photo credits: Tsai Ing-wen, Wikipedia; Michael Kovrig and Michael Spavor, Twitter; Irwin Cotler, Twitter; Marc Garneau, Twitter.


Now in its 15th year of publication. Reaching you where it matters.

If you would like to receive our future reports and articles, please sign up on the designated link located on this site. Your name and email address will never knowingly be shared with third parties.

Please leave a reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.